// FREE TOOL

Lead source profit calculator: which source pays you back

A lead source profit calculator compares every place your enquiries come from, such as hipages, Google Ads, Facebook Ads and referrals, on the cash each one collects and the profit left after its costs. Cost per lead tells you what a lead cost. It does not tell you whether the lead paid. Built by Web Blend, a Darwin agency that runs Google Ads, call tracking and ServiceM8 for Australian trades.

Updated October 2026. Checked against hipages Group's FY26 ASX filings.

Example
Example: the calculator filled in with its default numbers, then the result. Drawn mock-up; the numbers are made up.

// THE METHOD

The two-month method: one sheet, every source, same measure

Pick every source you pay for or get work from. Track each one for two months, longer if your jobs are big and slow to close. For each source, write down five numbers: what it cost, how many leads came in, how many became jobs, how much cash you actually collected, and your margin on that work.

Then ask one question per source: does the profit on the work it brought in cover what you paid for the leads, plus the monthly fees that come with it? If yes, keep it and think about turning it up. If no, it is costing you money to stay busy.

Two months matters. One good week on any platform proves nothing, and one bad week proves nothing either. Eight weeks is enough to see a pattern for most trades without burning a quarter's budget finding out.

The number that matters is profit per lead, not cost per lead. A $40 lead that closes 1 in 10 at a thin margin can lose money. A $120 lead that closes 1 in 3 can be the best money you spend.

Want the paper version? The two-month lead source tracker is a one-page sheet with the same columns. Tell us where to send it.

// YOUR SOURCES

Compare your lead sources

Enter one column per source. Use ex-GST figures and the same period for every column. Leave the defaults if you just want to see how the maths works. No signup. We keep anonymous stats on the numbers entered to improve the tool, never who you are.

Type your trade, industry or niche, or tap one:

Source 1
Source 2

Ranked by profit per lead
Rank Source Profit per lead Profit after costs Cash per lead Covers its costs?

// TRANSPARENT MATHS

How each number is worked out

Every result is arithmetic you can check on a calculator. Nothing is estimated.

Total cost        = fixed costs per month x months + leads x cost per lead
Cash per lead     = cash collected / leads
Profit after costs = cash collected x margin - total cost
Profit per lead   = profit after costs / leads
Break-even close rate = total cost / (leads x average paid job x margin)

A worked example with made-up numbers

These numbers are invented to show the maths. They are not client results and they are not a prediction. Your own two months decide it. All at a 40% gross margin.

Source 2-month cost Leads Jobs Cash collected Profit after costs Profit per lead
Marketplace: $249/mo plan, $35 a lead$1,898406$6,000$502$12.55
Google Ads, run yourself: $150/mo tracking, $80 a lead$1,900206$7,200$980$49.00
Same Google Ads, managed at $650/mo$3,200206$7,200-$320-$16.00
Referrals and repeat work$0106$6,000$2,400$240.00

Rows one and two cost almost the same per job, about $316. The difference is cash per lead: $150 against $360. That gap is the whole argument, and cost per lead hides it.

Row three is the same ads with a management fee added. At this budget the fee turns a profit into a loss. Paying someone to run ads makes sense when the budget or the jobs are big enough to carry the fee. On a small budget, running it yourself, or putting more of the money into the ads, can beat paying for management. We sell ad management, and we would rather you knew this before you rang us.

Row four costs nothing and earns the most per lead. Referral work is the benchmark every paid source is competing with.

// THE LEAD PRICE

Where the money in a marketplace lead goes

A marketplace lead price has to cover the platform's advertising, staff and profit before it reaches you. hipages Group reported $90.6 million of revenue and $22.9 million of EBITDA for the year to 30 June 2026, about 25 cents of earnings before interest, tax, depreciation and amortisation in every revenue dollar. That is a normal, listed business doing what listed businesses do.

The other half is sharing. hipages says up to 3 businesses can claim each lead, so the homeowner you call may be talking to two other tradies who paid for the same enquiry.

Your own ads still pay Google for the click, but there is no marketplace reselling the enquiry and no second or third buyer. They carry your time or a management fee, and they take weeks to tune. The calculator puts both on the same line so you are not comparing a lead price with an ad price.

Sources: hipages Group FY26 results and investor presentation, lodged with the ASX on 24 August 2026, as cited on our is hipages worth it page.

// TRACKING

The comparison is only as good as your tracking

Marketplace leads arrive labelled: you know which ones came from the app. Your own leads often do not. A customer sees your Google ad, rings the number off your website two days later, and the job gets written down as "website" or "word of mouth".

Three fixes close that gap. A separate tracked phone number for each source and each ad, so every call is labelled before you answer it. A tracked form on each landing page, so every form lead carries the ad and page that produced it. And a lead source field in your job system, so the source stays on the job until the invoice is paid. That last step is what turns "leads per source" into "cash collected per source".

Call tracking on its own is $150 + GST a month. A one-off conversion tracking setup on the site you already have is $750 + GST.

Write "unknown" when you do not know a lead's source. Do not guess. A column of honest unknowns tells you what to fix. A column of guesses tells you nothing.

Three numbered tracking fixes leading to cash collected per source: a tracked phone number for each source and each ad, a tracked form on each landing page, and a lead source field in your job system Example
Example: the three fixes that turn leads per source into cash collected per source.

// WHAT GOOD LOOKS LIKE

What a healthy lead source looks like after two months

// LIMITS

When this calculator will mislead you

If you are brand new and have no history, use planning mode with honest guesses, then come back with real numbers in two months. If your jobs take three months to quote and close, two months of cash collected will undercount every source, so run it for a longer period or count signed quotes as well. And if one source is paused for half the period, compare the months where both ran.

// QUESTIONS

Straight answers on lead source maths

Stuck on a number? Ask us and we will tell you how to measure it.

Get in touch
How do I work out which lead source makes me the most money?

Track every source for about two months. For each one, add up what it cost including monthly fees, then compare the cash you collected from its jobs, times your margin. Divide what is left by the number of leads. The source with the highest profit per lead is earning its place; any source below zero is costing you to stay busy.

Is cost per lead a good way to compare hipages and Google Ads?

Not on its own. A cheaper lead that rarely becomes a job can cost more per paid job than a dearer lead that does. Compare cash collected per lead and profit after costs instead.

Can the same money I spend on hipages fund my own ads?

Often, but check the fees first. At $600 to $700 a month you can run a small Google Ads campaign yourself; if you pay for management, the fee comes out of the same money, so run both versions through the calculator.

How long should I track before I decide?

Two months at minimum for most trades, and longer if your jobs are large or slow to close. Aim for at least 15 leads and 3 jobs per source before you trust the result.

What if most of my leads are "unknown"?

Fix tracking before you cut anything. A tracked phone number per source and per ad, a tracked form per landing page, and a lead source field in your job system will tell you within a month where your work really comes from.

Does Web Blend sell one of the options?

Yes. We set up Google Ads, call tracking and conversion tracking for trades, so we are not neutral. The calculator does not know that. It runs on your numbers, and the worked example on this page shows a case where paying us to manage ads would lose money.

// TWO MONTHS FROM NOW

Two months from now, you will know

Start tracking today and you will have a real answer before your next renewal. Get the tracker sheet, or have us set up the tracking for you: call tracking is $150 + GST a month.

See all free tools

// BEFORE YOU GO

Get the two-month lead source tracker

Tell us which lead sources you pay for. A person at Web Blend sends back our one-page tracker with the rows set up for your business, so in two months you know which source actually pays you.

  • A lead log, a monthly cost log and a two-month scorecard
  • Rows set up for the sources you name
  • What good looks like, so you know when to cut a source

A person at Web Blend sends this, usually within one business day. No list, no spam. See our privacy policy.